Feeds:
Posts
Comments

Posts Tagged ‘Gammill Numismatics’

Ira and Larry Goldberg’s auction of the Dan Holmes collection of Large Cents, in collaboration with Chris McCawley and Bob Grellman, will offer the large cent collector an opportunity to bid on a total of 68 NC varieties.  There are 55 NC varieties recognized by collectors and Dan was able to assemble 54 of the 55.  The one missing from his collection is the unique (1795 NC -5) which is located in the American Numismatic Societies Museum in NYC. 

In Dan’s collection of NC varieties there are 14 coins where there are duplicates.  Several of those NC varieties are of considerable interest and value.  For example, Lots 77 and 78 are examples of the 1794 NC-9, R7+.  Lot 77 is net graded Good-5 but the reverse vertical die crack is very weak (EDS, Breen state 1).  In the case of Lot 78, net graded About Good-3, the sharpness is slightly better and the reverse die crack is very strong indicating its LDS.  There are only four known examples of the 1794 NC-9 variety, two of which are in Holmes’ auction.  The census of these four examples are, 7-6-5-3.  The estimated value of these two lots is in the $20,000 range.  The VG-6 example was sold in February 2008 by Superior Galleries for $36,500.

Lots 129 and 130 offer two examples of the Jefferson Head 1795 NC-1, R8+.  Lot 129 is the “Unique” Thick Planchet Jefferson Head with Lettered Edge of 1793.   One of only three examples of the 1795 NC-1 and the only one struck on a thick planchet.  Graded by PCGS as Fine-15 and by McCawley/Grellman as Fine-12.  Estimated value for Lot 129 is $50,000.  Lot 130 is the thin planchet example of the NC-1 of which there are only two known examples.  Lot 130 grades as a Fair-2 with an estimated value of $20,000.  The second example has a grade of VF-20.

Lots 132 and 133 are also a pair of Jefferson Head NCs.  Lot 132 is the 1795 “Unique” Jefferson Head NC-4 (R8+) Thick Planchet Overstruck on a 1795 NC-1.  The coin is holed at the top of the head but is the second finer of only two known for the variety and grades Fair-2.  It is also unique that it is overstruck on an NC-1 thick planchet!  This varieties estimated value is $20,000 and UP.  This is truly a unique specimen.  Lot 133 is another “Unique” Jefferson Head NC-4.  This Jefferson Head is struck on a Thin Lettered Edge Planchet and grades Good-5.  The estimated value of this NC-4 is $30,000.

There is also Lots 394 and 395.  Lot 394 features an Outstanding 1800 NC-4 EDS.  It is the finest known of eight examples in all die states.  It grades EF-40 and is the Noyes plate coin.  Estimated value is $20,000.  Lot 395 is the 1800 NC-4 in MDS and grades Fair-2.  Estimated value is $4,000.

A complete listing of the NC varieties is listed in the table below.  It offers a unique opportunity for the large cent specialist.

Table:  A listing of the NC varieties in the Dan Holmes Collection being offered by Ira and Larry Goldberg on September 6, 2009.

Lot

Year

NC #

Rarity

Grade

Estimated  Value

Realized (+15%)

             

4

1793

NC-1

R8

BS1+

$10,000

 $28,750

7

1793

NC-2

R8+

PCGS Fair 2

$150,000

 264,500

8

1793

NC-3

R8-

PCGS G4

$150,000

 218,500

15

1793

NC-4

R7+

G6

$10,000

 27,600

17

1793

NC-5

R8+

EF45

$1,000

 6,325

25

1793

NC-6

R8

G4+

$20,000

 40,250

29

1794

NC-4(S-17b)

R8

AG3+

$10,000

 

34

1794

NC-7(S-20a)

R8+

G4

$10,000

 

40

1794

NC-8

R8-

F12

$20,000

 

41

1794

NC-11

R8

VG8

$20,000

 

57

1794

NC-1

R7+

G5

$10,000

 

64

1794

NC-2

R8

VG10

$20,000

 

70

1794

NC-10

R8+

F12

$20,000

 

72

1794

NC-5

R8

AG3

$20,000

 
             

77

1794

NC-9

R8-

G5

$20,000

 

78

1794

NC-9

R8-

AG3

$20,000

 
             

106

1794

NC-6

R8

F12

$30,000

 

115

1794

NC-3

R8

F12

$20,000

 

122

1795

NC-2

R8

AG3

$10,000

 

123

1795

NC-3

R7

AG3+

$5,000

 
             

129

1795

NC-1

R8+

PCGS F15

$50,000

 

130

1795

NC-1

R8

Fair 2

$20,000

 
             

132

1795

NC-4

R8+

Fair 2

$20,000

 

133

1795

NC-4

R8+

G5

$30,000

 
             

149

1796

NC-1

R6

VG7

$4,000

 

150

1796

NC-1

R6

VG8

$5,000

 
             

156

1796

NC-2

R7

VG10

$10,000

 

159

1796

NC-3

R6+

VF30

$20,000

 

160

1796

NC-3

R6+

VG10

$8,000

 
             

169

1796

NC-4

R5+

F15

$10,000

 

170

1796

NC-4

R5+

VG8

$4,000

 
             

188

1796

NC-5

R7

AG3

$4,000

 

201

1796

NC-6

R8

AG3

$10,000

 

205

1796

NC-7

R8

PCGS Fair 2

$20,000

 

208

1797

NC-1

R7

G6

$7,500

 
             

218

1797

NC-2

R6

VG8

$3,000

 

219

1797

NC-2

R6

VG10+

$5,000

 
             

220

1797

NC-3

R6-

G5

$2,000

 

221

1797

NC-3

R6-

VG8

$3,000

 
             

236

1797

NC-8

R8+

VF20+

$25,000

 

240

1797

NC-7

R8+

VG7

$25,000

 

243

1797

NC-6

R8

G4

$10,000

 

248

1797

NC-4

R8-

AG3

$10,000

 
             

258

1797

NC-5

R6

G6

$2,000

 

259

1797

NC-5

R6

VG8+

$4,000

 

283

1798

NC-1

R7+

AG3

$5,000

 

286

1798

NC-2

R7+

VG8

$15,000

 

287

1798

NC-2

R7+

VG8

$20,000

 
             

348

1799/8

NC-1

R7

F12

$50,000

 

356

1800/1798

NC-6

R6+

F15+

$10,000

 

357

1800/1798

NC-5

R8-

VG10+

$15,000

 

367

1800/179

NC-1

R8-

VG10

$15,000

 
             

368

1800/179

NC-2

R6+

VG7

$3,000

 

369

1800/179

NC-2

R6+

VG8

$2,000

 
             

377

1800

NC-3

R6-

VG8

$1,500

 
             

394

1800

NC-4

R7

EF40

$20,000

 

395

1800

NC-4

R7

Fair 2

$4,000

 
             

407

1801

NC-1

R5+

F12+

$5,000

 
             

415

1801

NC-2

R7

F15

$15,000

 

416

1801

NC-2

R7

BS1+

$1,000

 
             

417

1801

NC-5

R7+

AG3

$10,000

 

424

1801

NC-4

R7

VG8

$5,000

 

427

1801

NC-3

R6+

VG10

$5,000

 
             

438

1802

NC-1

R5+

G5

$500

 

439

1802

NC-1

R5+

EF45

$15,000

 
             

445

1802

NC-2

R6

VF25+

$10,000

 
             

493

1803

NC-1

R5+

VG7

$1,000

 

494

1803

NC-1

R5+

F15+

$7,500

 

Read Full Post »

20090425_172837_edited20090425_172749_edited

As you know, it’s hard to know what you might find when looking into a dealers showcase these days.  Recently I found two beautifully toned Milled Bust Pillar Dollars, both from the Mexico City Mint.  One from 1808 and the second from 1820.  While often referred to as a Pillar Dollar these coins are more accurately called Milled Bust Spanish Dollars.  The obverse of the 1808 example illustrates the bust of Charles IV while the reverse has the Pillars of Hercules, so familiar from the earlier Cobs.

There were a total of  twelve colonial mints located in; Mexico City, Santo Domingo, Lima, La Plata, Potosi, Panama City, Cartegena, Bogota, Cuzco, Guatemala, Santiago and Popayan.  These twelve mints produced a total of five different types of silver reales.  They were, pillar, shield, pillar and waves, milled pillar and milled bust (above 1808).  These were produced during Spain’s amazing 300 years of colonial rule.

The milled bust coins, also referred to as bust or portrait dollars,  were minted at the Mexico City mint from 1772 until 1821, when Mexico won its independence from Spain.  Like the milled pillar dollar, bust dollars circulated throughout the world, even serving as legal currency in the United States until 1857.   Mexico City coins are easily identified by their mintmark, an M with a small o above.

Read Full Post »

Over the years, as an avid collector of all things related to numismatics, I have talked to many colleagues who accurately regard themselves as true, “bona fide collectors”.  That is to say, they have absolutely no interest in discussing their collection as an investment instrument under any circumstance.  Well almost any circumstance.  They will rock back on their rears when they start talking about how much their AU-50 1909 S VDB cost them back in 1957.  Yes, they will remind you that they have made some good purchases over the years.  However, they most likely will say they have no desire or interest in “investment grade or investment quality coins” right after telling you about that very nice Lincoln cent.  They are investors aren’t they?  They say they are collectors and collect for the pure enjoyment of participating in the hobby.  They often remind you that it’s the hunt that drives them year after year, looking for that one special coin(s), book or piece of paper money to add to their collection…and they are dead serious and proud of that pursuit.  However, aren’t these collectors also investors by the simplest of definitions?  They have invested in America’s future by investing (collecting) in her past!

 

I know a number of collectors that fall under the definition of “bona fide collector” and they are some of the most knowledgeable and enjoyable people you will ever find when it comes to discussing collecting or any other topic as far as that goes.  I guess the simple point they make is that making money is not the most important aspect of their collecting activities.  Money has not been the driving force that has kept their interest in collecting alive over the many decades of what they consider a very nice leisure activity.  In addition to being quite knowledgeable about the history of the coin series they find most interesting, in general, they are always willing to share their collection with you, seek your opinion, giving new and young collectors sound advice and in the end, everyone gains an abundance of new knowledge and new friends.

 

If you talk to these people long enough you will generally find that they have no plans of ever selling their collection.  Talk to them a little longer and you will find out why they will never sale.  Very often, they are going to pass their collection on to future family generations.  I know one gentleman that has assembled five complete sets of Indian Head Cents in EF to MS 65.  They will go to his five grandchildren.  I have seen three of these sets and they are truly amazing.  Beautifully matched in color and quality and just about as problem free as you can imagine.  These sets have been assembled over a forty year period.  A truly remarkable task has been accomplished by this gentleman, reflecting on his own personal character as well as his dedication to pass not only his interests on to his children and future generations, but also the history of our country.

 

A second gentleman I met many years ago has put together three complete sets of Indian Head Cents for his grandkids.  To add to the hunt, he is attempting to upgraded each coin in every set to “four full diamonds”.  What a goal.  His sets are in the grade range of EF to AU 58.  Another wonderful accomplishment and he knows hel’ll never get full diamonds on all the coins, but he keeps looking.. 

 

I know individuals who have inherited multiple Lincoln Cent and Buffalo Nickel collections from a previous generation.  These people are not collectors but continue to hold the collections in hopes of future generations taking interest in a hobby enjoyed by a past generation.  These are remarkable coins that are properly stored and cared for and just waiting for their next custodian. 

 

I could go on but I think the point has been made.  These collectors have had a goal to leave something special to their families that gave them great enjoyment and satisfaction over many years.  They didn’t call themselves investors, but if fact they were.  All of these sets have greatly appreciated over the years.  It doesn’t matter who reaps the benefits of the financial gains, these gentleman have had a great experience collecting and assembling something they love and because they stuck with quality purchases, and made the key and semi-date purchases, they indeed have made a handsome investment over time. 

 

Any collection that has been assembled by a “bona fide collector”, as they might call themselves, stressing strike, luster and eye appeal, have done very well over the decades.  You don’t have to spend a million dollars, or make a million dollars on the sale of a collection to be both an astute collector as well as an investor. 

 

Collecting and investing in coins is synergistic!

 

COLLECT OR INVEST IN AMERICA’S FUTURE BY COLLECTING AND/OR INVESTING IN HER PAST!  IT IS TRULY AN AMAZING STORY FOR ALL GENERATIONS.

 

 

Read Full Post »

Another stunning treasure from the Dice-Hicks’ Collection of Hard Times Tokens was Lot 3129, another extremely rare Merchants Token from the historical seaport of New Orleans, Louisiana.  This lot was a brass, plain edge, Walton, Walker & Company token dated 1834. The token was engraved by Bale & Smith of New York.  It is Low 106, Rulau HT-129, 162.5 gns, 33.7 mm, with a rarity of R-7 (one of a handful known) and Struck Medal Turn.  The hammer price including the buyer’s fee was $63,250. 

The obverse: Walton, Walker & Co. 1834.  IMPORTERS OF AND DEALERS IN HARDWARES AND SHIP CHANDLERY No. 17 NEW LEVEE NEW ORLEANS. 

The reverse: FINE CUTLERY, GUNS, PISTOLS, IRON NAILS, CASTINGS DUPONTS POWDER MILL STONES &C.&C &C. 

This token has only been sold publicly two times in the past half century.  It was sold on June 23, 2004 (Lot 187) in the John J. Ford, Jr. Collection, Part IV where it sold for $48,875.  Previous to that it was listed in Ken Rendell’s Fixed Price List of September 5, 1958, consigned by Donald Miller; earlier, ex-Dupont and Tilden Collections.  We do not know what it was listed for on the Rendell Price List (which would be interesting, maybe someone has that infromation).  It was also auctioned in the 1916 Henry C. Miller collection sale.  Stacks makes the point in their description that this particular token is missing from almost all of the great Hard Times Tokens collections ever auctioned (including the Krause, Zeddies, Steinberg and Litman collections).  That puts it in perspective in terms of rarity!

To view this token go to this “link”.

Read Full Post »